August 1, 2022 • 1hr 35min

Dr. Emily Balcetis: Tools for Setting & Achieving Goals

Huberman Lab

In this episode, Dr. Andrew Huberman interviews Dr. Emily Balcetis, Professor of Psychology at New York University, about her research on how visual perception influences motivation, goal setting, and goal achievement. Dr. Balcetis explains how adjusting our visual focus and perception can be used as a tool to improve performance and motivation across various domains. The discussion covers both the scientific mechanisms behind these effects as well as practical strategies people can apply to their own goals.

0:00

-0:00

Key Takeaways

Narrowing visual focus can improve exercise performance - Studies show that adopting a narrow visual focus (like a spotlight) on a target ahead can help people move 27% faster and perceive exercise as 17% less painful.
Visual perception impacts motivation and goal achievement - How we visually perceive goals and challenges affects our motivation and ability to achieve them. Making goals appear visually closer can increase motivation.
Visualizing obstacles improves goal attainment - Mentally visualizing potential obstacles and how to overcome them in advance leads to better goal achievement compared to only visualizing success.
Data tracking enhances goal progress - Using apps or tools to objectively track progress towards goals provides more accurate feedback than relying on memory alone.
Visual strategies can be applied to non-physical goals - Techniques like narrowing visual focus can also be used for cognitive goals like learning an instrument or language.
States of the body influence visual perception - Physical states like fatigue or being overweight can make distances appear farther and hills steeper, impacting motivation.
Visual tools may have applications for mental health - Visual perception strategies could potentially be used to help with conditions like depression and anxiety.

Introduction

In this episode, Dr. Andrew Huberman interviews Dr. Emily Balcetis, Professor of Psychology at New York University, about her research on how visual perception influences motivation, goal setting, and goal achievement. Dr. Balcetis explains how adjusting our visual focus and perception can be used as a tool to improve performance and motivation across various domains. The discussion covers both the scientific mechanisms behind these effects as well as practical strategies people can apply to their own goals.

Topics Discussed

Vision and Motivation (8:08)

Dr. Balcetis explains that while many common motivation strategies like self-pep talks require ongoing effort, visual perception strategies can be more automatic and effortless. Her research explores how adjusting visual perception and focus can impact motivation and goal achievement.

Visual perception strategies are more automatic and require less ongoing effort than traditional motivation techniques
How we visually perceive goals impacts our motivation to pursue them
Visual perception is a dominant sense that can be leveraged for motivation

Narrowing Visual Focus to Improve Exercise (11:37)

Dr. Balcetis describes studies showing that adopting a narrow visual focus on a target ahead can significantly improve exercise performance:

Elite athletes reported using a narrow "spotlight" focus during competitions
In studies, teaching people to narrow their visual focus led to:
- 27% faster movement speed during a challenging exercise
- Perceiving the exercise as 17% less painful
Narrowing visual focus creates an illusion of the goal being closer, increasing motivation

"We helped them to move faster, burn calories at a higher rate...exercise more efficiently. The amount of time they put in is going to produce a better physical outcome. And it also didn't hurt them as much." - Dr. Emily Balcetis

Adjusting Visual Attention and Perceived Fatigue (21:39)

The discussion explores how physical states like fatigue influence visual perception of the environment:

Studies show people who are fatigued, elderly, or overweight perceive distances as farther and hills as steeper
Giving people glucose energy led them to perceive distances as shorter
These perceptual changes impact motivation and willingness to take on physical challenges

Visual Focus "Spotlight" Tool (25:14)

Dr. Balcetis provides guidance on how to implement the visual spotlight technique:

Imagine a circular spotlight illuminating a target ahead
Focus attention within that spotlight, tuning out peripheral distractions
For longer distances, choose intermediate targets to spotlight sequentially
The technique induces an illusion of proximity that increases motivation

Goal Gradient Hypothesis and Visual Spotlight (27:57)

The discussion covers how the visual spotlight technique leverages the goal gradient hypothesis:

The goal gradient hypothesis states that effort increases as people get closer to a goal
Narrowing visual focus creates an illusion of being closer to the goal
This illusion triggers increased effort and motivation, even when fatigued

Defining vs. Accomplishing Goals (35:00)

Dr. Balcetis explains potential pitfalls of common goal-setting techniques like vision boards:

Simply visualizing achieving a goal can reduce motivation to pursue it
Visualizing success lowers blood pressure, reducing physiological readiness for action
More effective techniques involve breaking goals into concrete steps and visualizing obstacles

"Creating these dream boards, these vision boards, or to-do lists might actually backfire, because in and of itself is the creation of a goal and the satisfaction of the goal. And then people understandably give themselves some time to just enjoy that positive experience." - Dr. Emily Balcetis

Setting Better Goals and Identifying Obstacles (41:28)

Dr. Balcetis outlines a more effective goal-setting process:

Define the big picture goal
Break it down into concrete, manageable steps
Visualize potential obstacles and how to overcome them
Mentally preparing for obstacles improves ability to overcome them

Vision is Unique and Challenging the Visual System (46:38)

The discussion explores why vision is a particularly powerful sense for motivation:

Vision occupies more neural real estate than other senses
Visual perception is rarely second-guessed or corrected by other senses
Visual illusions reveal how powerfully vision shapes our perception of reality

Do Fit People View the World Differently? (57:12)

The conversation examines how physical fitness impacts visual perception:

Studies show fit people tend to perceive distances as shorter and hills as less steep
These perceptual differences can create a positive feedback loop for motivation
Visual perception techniques can help less fit people overcome these perceptual barriers

Caffeine, Stimulants and Visual Windows (1:05:54)

Dr. Huberman discusses how stimulants like caffeine impact visual perception:

Stimulants tend to narrow visual focus, similar to the spotlight technique
This narrowed focus may contribute to caffeine's motivational effects
Combining caffeine with intentional visual focusing could enhance motivation

Goal Setting for Cognitive Goals (1:10:13)

The discussion explores applying visual techniques to non-physical goals:

Visual highlighting can aid language learning
Apps like "1 Second Everyday" can provide visual progress tracking
Objective data tracking helps overcome faulty memory of progress

Year in Review and Memory (1:21:54)

Dr. Balcetis shares how visual tools can enhance memory and goal tracking:

Apps like "1 Second Everyday" create visual montages of progress over time
These visual summaries can trigger powerful memories and emotions
Visual data tracking provides more accurate progress assessment than memory alone

Visual Tools and Mental Health (1:26:32)

The conversation explores potential applications of visual perception tools for mental health:

Depression and anxiety influence what people visually attend to in their environment
Intentionally directing visual attention to positive stimuli may help counteract negative biases
More research is needed on applying visual motivation tools to mental health

Focusing Attention and Increasing Visual Detail (1:31:33)

The discussion examines how intentional visual focus impacts brain activity:

Neuroimaging shows focusing visual attention activates relevant brain regions
Intentional focus can override automatic visual processing
This demonstrates the power of top-down control over visual perception

Conclusion

This episode provides a fascinating look at how visual perception influences motivation and goal achievement. Dr. Balcetis's research reveals that relatively simple adjustments to how we visually perceive goals and challenges can have significant impacts on our motivation and performance. The discussion outlines several practical visual tools and strategies that listeners can apply to their own goals, from narrowing visual focus during exercise to using apps for visual progress tracking. While more research is needed, these visual perception techniques show promise for application across a wide range of domains, from physical fitness to cognitive goals to potentially even mental health. Overall, the episode highlights the power of leveraging our visual system to enhance motivation and goal attainment.